Compare Pets Best vs. Nationwide Pet Insurance

We believe in providing a non-biased comparison to better inform you of the similarities and differences between common plan and service items that customers routinely ask about when looking for pet health insurance.

When comparing coverage, Nationwide and Pets Best Pet Insurance both have annual plans, available wellness plans, an unlimited annual and lifetime benefit plan, and have coverage for accident and illness exam fees, and prescription medications. Both Nationwide and Pets Best offer accident and illness plans with full hereditary and congenital coverage as well.

Pets Best offers more flexible plan options with the ability to choose your annual deductible, reimbursement percentage, as well as your annual limit. Also, all accident and illness pet insurance plans Pets Best offers are reimbursed based on a percentage of your vet bill after meeting your deductible instead a schedule of benefits. Pets Best also has no upper age limits for all accident and illness plans for pets enrolling over the age of 9.

When comparing Claims and Customer Commitment, Pets Best has more customer support options with chat support capabilities. Both Nationwide and Pets Best offer a 24/7 Pet Helpline for all pet parents to be able to talk or live chat with veterinary experts with any question you have concerning your pet's health.

Check out the comparison chart below to learn more.

Coverage Comparison

 Pets BestNationwide
Unlimited Annual & Lifetime Benefit Plan  
Annual Deductibles  
Optional Accident and Illness Exam Fee Coverage  
Prescription Medication Coverage  
Full Hereditary and Congenital Coverage  
Routine Care Coverage  
No Upper Age Limits on Accident & Illness Plans  
Submit Claims from Any Device  
Claims Pre-Approval  
Optional Vet Direct Pay  
Online Policy and Claims Management  
Chat Support  
Mobile App  
24/7 Pet Helpline  
Veterinarian Founded  

A Real Pet Insurance Quote Example

Lewis, 3 / Mixed Breed Dog

Meet Lewis - a real pet quoted with Pets Best and Nationwide*

Pets BestNationwide
90% Covered90% Covered
$250 Annual Deductible$250 Annual Deductible
Unlimited Annual LimitUnlimited Annual Limit

* Quotes obtained online on 8/25/2020 using a 3 year old mixed breed dog in San Diego, CA 92132 with the maximum allowable annual or per incident limit from each company. Sample pricing does not include any extra fees, taxes, or administrative charges. Nationwide plan compared included wellness coverage. Pets Best plan compared included BestWellnessTM routine care option.